Most people expect some soreness after receiving a vaccination. What they don’t expect is an injury that leaves them unable to raise their arm, sleep comfortably, or perform ordinary activities without pain.
Yet that sometimes happens. A vaccination intended to protect a person’s health can, if the person administering it places the injection improperly, injure the structures of the shoulder itself. Physicians call this condition Shoulder Injury Related to Vaccine Administration, or SIRVA.
The National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP), a federal program established to compensate individuals injured by certain vaccines, recognizes SIRVA as a compensable injury under specified circumstances. But establishing that an injury occurred after a vaccination is not the same as proving that the vaccination caused it. And even when the connection seems obvious, the law imposes additional requirements before someone can receive compensation.
Understanding those requirements, and the evidence you need to satisfy them, can make an enormous difference in the outcome of a claim.
What Is SIRVA?
Healthcare providers ordinarily inject vaccines into the deltoid muscle of the upper arm. When someone places the injection too high or allows the needle or vaccine material to reach tissues surrounding the shoulder joint, the injection can injure structures that include the bursa, tendons, and ligaments.
Physicians may diagnose the resulting condition as bursitis, tendinitis, rotator cuff damage, or another inflammatory injury affecting the shoulder.
This differs from the ordinary soreness that frequently follows vaccination. Routine injection-site discomfort generally resolves without significant intervention. SIRVA can involve persistent pain, restricted movement, and functional limitations that continue for months or longer.
Nor does SIRVA necessarily involve a reaction to the chemical or biological properties of the vaccine. It generally results from the manner in which someone administers the injection.
That distinction matters because the VICP operates as a no-fault compensation program. In a qualifying SIRVA case, you do not have to prove that the pharmacist, nurse, or other person administering the vaccine acted negligently. Instead, you must establish that your injury satisfies the requirements of the Vaccine Act and its implementing regulations.
What You Must Prove
The Vaccine Injury Table, found at 42 C.F.R. § 100.3, establishes specific criteria for SIRVA. When a petitioner demonstrates that an injury satisfies those criteria following a covered vaccination, the law generally presumes that the vaccine caused the injury, unless the government establishes another cause.
Four requirements govern a SIRVA claim under the Vaccine Injury Table.
First, you must establish the condition of your shoulder before vaccination. You must show that you had no prior history of pain, inflammation, or dysfunction in the affected shoulder that would explain the symptoms you experienced afterward. This does not necessarily mean that you must have had a perfectly healthy shoulder. But a preexisting shoulder condition may complicate your claim, particularly if it could explain your subsequent symptoms.
Second, you must establish when the pain began. The Vaccine Injury Table requires shoulder pain to begin within 48 hours of vaccination. This is one of the most important elements of a SIRVA claim. You do not have to see a physician within those 48 hours, but you must present credible evidence that your shoulder pain began during that period. You must also establish reduced range of motion, although that limitation need not begin within the same 48-hour period.
Third, you must establish the location of your symptoms. Your shoulder pain and reduced range of motion must involve the shoulder in which you received the vaccination. If you received a vaccination in your left arm, for example, an unrelated injury to your right shoulder would not satisfy this requirement.
Fourth, you must rule out other explanations for your symptoms. A cervical spine disorder, neurological condition, or unrelated shoulder injury may produce symptoms similar to SIRVA. The court must determine whether another condition adequately explains your complaints.
These four requirements establish the medical and factual criteria for a SIRVA Table injury. You must also satisfy the Vaccine Act’s other eligibility requirements, including those concerning the vaccine you received, where you received it, and whether you previously obtained compensation for the same injury.
You must satisfy a separate statutory severity requirement as well.
In most SIRVA cases, you must prove that the residual effects of your injury continued for more than six months after vaccination. The Act also provides alternative paths involving an injury that causes inpatient hospitalization and surgical intervention, or death, but those circumstances rarely arise in an ordinary shoulder injury claim.
Notice what the six-month requirement does not say. It does not require six months of physical therapy, six months of physician visits, or six months of prescription medication. It requires proof that the injury’s effects persisted for more than six months.
That distinction can decide a case.
What You Should Tell Your Doctor
When someone contacts me about a possible SIRVA claim, one of the first things I want to understand is the medical history. What was the condition of the shoulder before vaccination? When did the pain begin? What happened afterward? What did the examining physicians observe?
Medical records that physicians create during treatment generally carry substantial evidentiary weight. Physicians prepare those records to diagnose and treat medical problems, not to support legal claims years later.
Unfortunately, patients do not always appreciate how important it is to communicate the relevant facts clearly.
Suppose you received an influenza vaccination in your left arm on Monday afternoon. That evening, you began experiencing pain deep in your shoulder. Several days later, you found that raising your arm above your head had become difficult. When you finally visited your physician, you described the problem simply as shoulder pain.
Your doctor might accurately record your complaint without mentioning the vaccination, when the symptoms began, or whether you had experienced similar problems before.
Months later, when those facts become important to a Vaccine Court claim, the medical record may say nothing about precisely the matters you must establish.
My advice is simple: Tell your doctor exactly what happened, including when it happened.
Explain when and where you received the vaccination, which arm received the injection, when the pain began, and how the symptoms developed. Describe any prior shoulder problems candidly. Explain what activities you can no longer perform comfortably, whether you have difficulty sleeping, and whether your shoulder movement has become restricted.
Be specific. Saying that your shoulder hurts gives your doctor useful information. Explaining that you cannot reach overhead to retrieve something from a cabinet, fasten a seat belt, or sleep on the affected side tells the physician considerably more about the functional consequences of your injury.
Ask your doctor to examine and document your range of motion. Your physician may recommend physical therapy, an orthopedic consultation, ultrasound, MRI, or other diagnostic studies. Not every SIRVA claim requires imaging, and an MRI does not, by itself, establish or disprove the claim. The significance of any study depends on the medical findings and the condition your physician evaluates.
You should not ask a physician to manufacture a diagnosis or record symptoms you have not experienced. Nor should you conceal an earlier shoulder injury because you fear it might affect your claim. Inaccurate or incomplete histories can undermine both your medical care and your credibility.
The objective is not to construct a favorable record. It is to create an accurate one.
If you later discover that a medical note contains a factual error, bring it to your physician’s attention and ask the office to address it through its ordinary correction procedures. Correcting an error openly, based on the facts, is very different from trying to rewrite an unfavorable history.
What Records Should You Keep?
An injury claim ultimately requires you to establish historical facts. Some of those facts may seem obvious today but become difficult to prove two years later.
I recommend preserving the following:
- Vaccination records. Keep documentation identifying the vaccine, the date and location of administration, the provider, and, if available, the manufacturer and lot number. Record which arm received the injection. If you received the vaccine at a pharmacy, workplace clinic, or temporary vaccination site, preserve any receipts, appointment confirmations, or related correspondence.
- Medical records before and after vaccination. Records preceding the vaccination can help establish the condition of your shoulder before the injury. Subsequent physician notes, physical therapy evaluations, imaging reports, specialist consultations, and treatment summaries can establish what happened afterward.
- Prescription and treatment records. Preserve pharmacy receipts, medication histories, physical therapy records, and documentation of injections or other treatments. These records can help establish both the nature of your injury and the duration of its effects.
- A contemporaneous account of your symptoms. Keep a dated journal describing pain, restricted motion, interrupted sleep, missed activities, and your attempts to manage your symptoms. You need not write an elaborate account. Its value comes from recording accurate, specific information while the events remain fresh in your mind.
- Evidence of the injury’s practical and financial consequences. Keep medical bills, insurance statements, receipts for unreimbursed expenses, and records of missed work or lost earnings. Family members, coworkers, or others who personally observed your difficulties may also provide useful evidence.
One additional point deserves emphasis. If your physician recommends treatment, follow the medical advice appropriate to your circumstances. If expense, scheduling difficulties, or other legitimate concerns prevent you from continuing treatment, explain those circumstances to your provider and ask about medically appropriate alternatives.
You should not undergo unnecessary medical treatment merely to create a legal record. But neither should you assume that you can easily establish an undocumented period of continuing pain years afterward.
What Happens If You Stop Treatment but Continue Experiencing Pain?
I take this question particularly seriously because I litigated a SIRVA case in which the government sought to dismiss my client’s claim principally because of a substantial gap in her medical treatment.
My client discontinued physical therapy less than four months after vaccination because of financial and scheduling difficulties. Her shoulder injury had not resolved, but her medical records did not document continuous treatment through the six-month statutory threshold.
The Department of Justice argued that she had failed to establish the required duration of her injury and asked the Vaccine Court to dismiss her petition.
I disagreed.
The contemporaneous medical records showed that she continued experiencing symptoms when formal treatment ended. We supplemented those records with pharmacy evidence and sworn testimony from my client and a family member who had personally observed her continuing limitations.
In April 2024, Chief Special Master Brian H. Corcoran ruled in her favor. He found that the later testimony did not contradict the medical records. Instead, the testimony complemented them, and the medical records supported it. After considering the evidence as a whole, the court concluded that her injury had persisted beyond the statutory threshold.
The decision does not mean that testimony can overcome every gap in medical treatment. Each case turns on its own evidence. But it illustrates why the absence of continuing medical appointments does not necessarily prove that an injury has resolved.
What matters is whether the evidence, considered as a whole, establishes the facts the law requires.
How Much Time Do You Have to File a Claim?
Prospective petitioners need to understand another timing requirement.
For injury claims under the VICP, the general filing deadline runs three years from the first symptom or manifestation of the injury’s onset, or its significant aggravation.
That is the statute of limitations. It differs from the six-month severity requirement.
If you confuse the two, you may lose the opportunity to pursue an otherwise legitimate claim. Continuing medical treatment does not ordinarily extend the filing deadline, and the law recognizes only limited exceptions.
If you believe you have suffered a vaccine-related shoulder injury, consult an attorney well before the deadline approaches.
The VICP covers certain vaccines, including seasonal influenza vaccines, tetanus-containing vaccines, and several other routinely administered vaccines. Currently, a separate federal program, the Countermeasures Injury Compensation Program, handles claims involving COVID-19 vaccines. That program imposes different eligibility requirements and filing deadlines. Determining which program governs your claim should form part of your initial legal evaluation.
For qualifying Vaccine Court petitions, the compensation program generally pays reasonable attorney fees and litigation costs, subject to the applicable requirements of good faith and reasonable basis. The program ordinarily pays these fees separately rather than deducting them from a petitioner’s compensation award.
Having an Injury Is Not the Same as Proving a Claim
The Vaccine Court does not award compensation simply because someone experiences shoulder pain after a vaccination. Nor does it demand medical or scientific certainty about every disputed fact.
The law generally requires a petitioner to establish the necessary facts by a preponderance of the evidence. In practical terms, you must show that the facts supporting your claim are more likely true than not.
That requires a critical examination of the evidence. We must evaluate medical records in context, consider competing explanations, and address inconsistencies rather than ignore them. At the same time, we should not dismiss credible testimony merely because the person gave it after the events in question.
When I evaluate a potential SIRVA claim, I want to know what happened before deciding what we can prove. Sometimes the evidence establishes a sound basis for proceeding. Sometimes it does not. An attorney owes a prospective client an informed assessment of that distinction.
If I accept a client, it is because I believe there is a legitimate claim worth pursuing. My job then is to identify the legal requirements, examine the evidence honestly, and develop the strongest case the facts will support.
A vaccine injury may occur in a matter of seconds. Establishing the right to compensation can require considerably more work.
That work begins with an accurate account of what happened, careful medical documentation, and an understanding of what the law actually requires.
Provenzo Law PLLC represents individuals seeking compensation through the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program. If you experienced persistent shoulder pain or restricted movement following vaccination, contact the firm to discuss your circumstances and whether you may have a compensable claim.
This article provides general information, not legal advice concerning a particular claim. Each case depends on its own facts, medical evidence, and applicable law. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.